Top 6 Fresh Dog Food Subscriptions, Ranked

A dog with a bowl of homemade dog food (Photo by Zontica on Shutterstock)

Opening a can of dog food might be convenient, but is it the healthiest choice for your pet? Probably not. Prepackaged options often contain fillers and preservatives that can compromise your dog’s long-term health. On the other hand, the best fresh food subscriptions give you options that are packed with whole ingredients, offering superior nutrition, improved digestion, and a shinier coat.

Instead of spending hours cooking for your dog, consider a service that delivers fresh food right to your door. These subscription-based services are becoming increasingly popular, offering customized meals tailored to your dog’s age, size, and dietary needs, making balanced nutrition easy and hassle-free. But which services give you the most value? While we haven’t tried them all, we put together this list of the best fresh dog food subscriptions that experts recommend. Did we miss one that you and your pet adore? Let us know below!

StudyFinds compiles lists of consensus picks featured on credible review sites. We aim to lay out top consumer research finds for you by bringing expert rankings to one place.

Experts say these are the best fresh dog food subscriptions:

1. The Farmer’s Dog

The Farmer’s Dog takes the crown for the best fresh dog food, thanks to high-quality ingredients, tailored meal plans, and eco-friendly packaging that fits neatly in your fridge. While all recipes are grain-free, the personalized approach, guided by veterinary nutritionists, ensures your dog’s unique needs are met. Sadie Cornelius from Canine Journal shares that her Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, Lexie, loves the food, has lost weight, and has a shinier coat.

Mas and Pas raves about this fresh food delivery program because it’s a breeze to customize. The meals are USDA-certified, nutritionally balanced, and even come with your dog’s name on the packets—a nice personal touch. Plus, the eco-friendly packaging and top-notch customer service make it a win all around!

The Farmer’s Dog Beef Recipe is a top pick by Dog Food Advisor because it contains 39 percent protein and 29 percent fat from fresh beef. The food is naturally moist and free from feed-grade ingredients. Plus, it’s great for all dog sizes and breeds.

2. Nom Nom

Nom Nom offers fresh, pre-portioned meals crafted by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, and it’s a top pick according to Forbes. While it can be pricey, the brand’s meals are well-balanced and highly recommended by vets like Dr. Erica Irish. With easy delivery and transparent ingredients, Nom Nom is a standout choice for your pet’s nutrition.

Mas and Pas loves that each pack is perfectly portioned for one meal, eliminating the need for leftovers. The easy-peel packets are a breeze to open with no scissors needed. In addition, the compact, soft plastic pouches take up minimal freezer space, making storage a cinch!

What makes this service stand out is the money-back guarantee, the option to try a variety of sample packs before subscribing, and the flexibility to order half meals for larger dogs. Canine Journal believes it’s all about finding the perfect fit for your pup without commitment. With these thoughtful options, it’s no wonder it’s a top pick!

3. Ollie

If the goal of a fresh food diet is for your dog to lose weight, Ollie’s system is a game-changer, even adjusting portion sizes to help your dog shed pounds. The canine tester at Rover.com couldn’t get enough of the dry-ish pâté, and her human loves the convenience of each package containing a full day’s worth of food. It’s a win-win for both pups and their owners! 

Ollie’s food smells so good, that even a Forbes editor was tempted to take a bite! The downsides? The meals can only be customized for calories and allergies, not all health needs. Plus, those large packages can make freezer space a challenge!

Ollie’s customized scopper helps take the guesswork out of feeding your dog the perfect portion. According to Mas and Pas, reviewers rave about the food’s quality, and many appreciate that Ollie offers chicken—a protein sometimes missing from other brands.

4. PetPlate

Developed by Dr. Streeter, PetPlate offers balanced, human-grade meals with the bonus of organic treats and supplement cookies for digestion and mobility. With customizable options like Barkin’ Beef and Chompin’ Chicken, Forbes says the meals are a hit for dogs of all breeds and needs. All meals can be served cold or warm in microwave-safe and recyclable containers.

Want to mix and match recipes? Not a problem, according to Business Insider, which highlights PetPlate as the only fresh dog food subscription allowing that. Plus, you can order smaller portions to supplement kibble, and the detailed feeding guide makes portioning and warming a breeze.

PetPlate uses sturdy plastic tubs, making it easy to store leftovers. Just pop the lid, scoop out what you need, and seal it back up—no need to transfer leftovers to another container like with soft plastic packaging from other brands. It’s a simple and convenient way to keep your dog’s meals fresh, so says Mas and Pas.

5. JustFoodForDogs

Veterinary nutritionists at JustFoodForDogs craft customized prescription meals tailored to your dog’s medical records. While pricier than other fresh meal plans, Forbes notes that cost includes access to veterinarians for questions.

JustFoodForDogs meets all WSAVA Global Nutrition Guidelines, employing full-time veterinary nutritionists to ensure food safety and high nutritional value. Business Insider likes that the company’s use of feeding trials to prove the nutrition and digestibility of its food is rare in the fresh pet food industry.

The Turkey and Whole Wheat Macaroni stands out in JustFoodForDogs’ lineup which includes nine fresh choices with no fillers or artificial additives. Made from fresh turkey this formula is also 100 percent free of feed-grade ingredients. Though it ships only on select days, it’s a top fresh pick by Dog Food Advisor. 

6. Spot and Tango

If you’re not ready to give up dry kibble but want a healthier option, Forbes recommends Spot & Tango’s UnKibble. Unlike traditional kibble, UnKibble is made without meat meals or powdered “mystery meats” and comes in flavors like Beef & Barley, Chicken & Brown Rice, and Cod & Salmon.

According to Mas and Pas, the UnKibble is perfect for pet parents who like the convenience of kibble but want the health benefits of fresh ingredients. Spot and Tango also offers wet meals that meet AAFCO guidelines for complete and balanced nutrition across all life stages.

Rover.com adds that Spot & Tango’s fresh recipes also deliver omega-3s with fish oil, essential for your puppy’s growth. These grain-inclusive options come in three mouthwatering flavors: turkey & red quinoa, beef & millet, and lamb & brown rice.

Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. StudyFinds is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This article may contain affiliate links in which we receive a commission if you make a purchase.